Friday, January 27, 2012

Obamacare HHS mandate

This blog is dedicated to Pope John Paul II. One of the great legacies of this holy Pope was his teaching on Human Sexuality- The Theology of the Body. By and large this gem of Catholic teaching has been ignored by most of the Church. This is a shame because the teachings highlight the incredible dignity of the human person created in the image of God. The Second Vatican Council used the phrase "Total Vision of Man" in applying the church's teaching to these issues. So how does this apply to issues in the church today? Last Friday Kathleen Sebelius and the HHS department announced a mandate for contraceptive coverage. This mandate would apply to abortificients, contraceptives, and sterilization. This may leave some Catholics scratching their heads. Why focus on contraception when there are so many other issues, and doesn't contraception help reduce unwanted pregnancies? Dating back to Humanae Vitae, the encyclical on the regulation of human birth, there has been a split in the Catholic Community. Many Catholics simply chose to ignore this church teaching as out of date and not pertinent to modern times. This is unfortunate. Consider the following statistics from Walter Schu's book, The Splendor of Love: " In light of Paul VI's first prophesy, let us review once again the dire statistics on marriage and public morality since the 1960's which ushered in the widespread use of contraception......In what was called the 'demoralization of American societ,' a number of statistical indicators came together. In the 30 years 1960-1990, while the U.S. population rose by 41%, there was a 560 percent increase in violent crime, 200 percent in teenage suicide, 200 percent increase in divorce, over 400 percent increase in illegitimate births, 300 percent rise in childern living in single parent homes-producing in toto the significant fact tht children formed the fastest growing segment of the criminal population.........Up to 1920, the proportion of children born to single women in the United States was less than 3 percent, roughly where it had been throughout the history of the country...By the end of 1994 it (the illegitimacy rate) was 33 percent for the nation as a whole, 25 percent for whites, and 70 percent for blacks. In parts of Washington D.C, capital of the richest nation in the world, it was as high as 90 %. " Schu, LC continues in his book, "Pope Paul VI expressed special concern about the vulnerability of the young. Critics dismissed his worries with indulgent smiles. Are young people suffering today as a result of contraception? Consider the following stats from the Washington Weekly standard, 1996: " By age 19 8 out of every 10 males and 7 of 10 females has had sexual intercourse. Four of 10 teenagers have had at least one pregnancy....Nearly a million and a half abortions occur each year and nearly a third of these (almost 400,000) are obtained by teenagers.... These figures are so chilling; so too is their meaning. It is disturbing that they seem to be self-perpetuating; consider that roughly 80 percent of girls who are mothers at age 15 are daughters of women who had babies when they were teenagers."

I think it is fair to conclude that Pope Paul VI was correct when he said there would be a general decline in morality in the population. Secondly, he wrote that "man who becomes used to contraceptive devices, may in the end lose respect for his wife, and no longer caring about her physical and psychological well being, will come to the point of considering her a mere instrument of selfish enjoyment, and no longer his respected and beloved companion. Lastly, Paul VI expressed concern that contraception would be a "dangerous weapon that would thus be placed in the hands of those public authorities who have no concern for the requirements of morality." In a strongly worded sentence Pope Paul VI notes: "Who will prevent rulers from favoring, and even imposing upon their people, the methold of contraception they judge to be the most effective, if they should consider this to be necessary?" Indeed, this is where we are today, the Obama Administration has given, in the words of Archbishop Dolan, a year before they have to violate their conscience. Although the issue is serious and points to questions of religious liberty, it is also a great starting point to begin a discussion of why the church teaches what it does. Worth noting is that every major Christian denomination opposed artificial means of contraception until the Lambeth Conference in the 1930's. The Catholic Church is the only Church that has remained firm in declaring it to be a grave moral evil. This teaching, interestingly enough, was the thing that convinced Dr. Scott Hahn's wife, Kimberly, to enter the church. If the church were right on this issue she must be right on the other issues as well. "This teaching is hard!" we say like the Apostles. Yes, it is hard, but in future blog posts I hope to demonstrate the reasonableness of this teaching, how it fits into the "Total Vision of Man" and how if we give the Lord the best of ourselves, even our sexuality and fertility, The Lord of Life will not be outdone in generosity. Praised be Jesus Christ.....and Long Live Christ the King!

Fr Nagle


  1. Dear Fr. Nagle. Thanks for stating it the way it should be stated! It is great to have priests who are willing and ready to stand for the truth and for religious liberty in America. Good work and keep it up!

  2. Excellent first post Father Nagle! Completely agree with Steve's comment above, it's a blessing to have priests such as yourself who are willing and ready to stand for the truth instead of ignoring such important issues as human sexuality and how it relates to God's will. In our own example we began with a rough start and our message from God came via. a Priest's persistence on this issue. Giving in to God's will has made our relationship stronger and closer while at the same time blessing our family with gifts that only God could offer. Father Nagle, keep up the good fight. We miss your weekly homilies and keep you in our prayers across pond. God Bless!